The Fly in the Ointment
By J. Russell Crabtree
Have
you ever wondered why it is that groupings of churches create
fellowships or denominations? What purpose do they serve? After they
have been established, why do they not help the very congregations
which gave them reason for being?
J. Russell Crabtree takes on
an extremely difficult issue relative to District, Regional, and
National church organizations. The status quo leader at any of these
level may have little interest in what Crabtree has to say. The man or
woman who is a servant/leader to groupings of churches and who is
always in critique mode of how serving and leading best happens will
find this book a stimulating read.
The Fly in the Ointment
is written primarily to a mainline church audience.However, once a
person does the translation from region to district and makes allowances
for polity differences, this book will challenge evangelical and
Pentecostal conventional thinking.
While I agree with most but
not all of the book, I do appreciate that Crabtree is not
"pie-in-the-sky." He understands budgets, bylaws, governance, the
church and Districts (Regions). He is very practical in his advice to
leaders.
The book's description of
mono-optional cultures to multi-optional cultures is fascinating; it is
profound yet simple. In describing life on a variety of fronts in the
1950s he shows we had few options: cars - Ford or Chevy (but not both);
tissue - Kleenex; overseas travel - TWA; business machines - IBM;
churches - Baptist, Assemblies of God, Presbyterian, or Catholic
(certainly not all of the above).
In the 60s and 70s we began to
learn of options and those options included church options. If we were
raised AG, we could change and go to the Baptist or Independent church
and God wouldn't get made at us. As we approach 2010, brand loyalty is
in the glossary of terms of business history books. Unfortunately,
many of the church organizations that grew out of the early and
mid-years of the 20th century do not connect with the idea that a
local church has options today.
Crabtree is an optimist. While
rightly researching regional/district bodies to the fullest extent, he
offers solutions in his Regional Association Assessment Tool ©. In the final chapter of The Fly in the Ointment he gives a five-step process to getting started, beginning with finding out where you are today in service to the church.
District, regional, and national work is not easy. Crabtree notes that,
when taking a northbound highway out of Honolulu, you come to a place
called Pali Pass. At that point, if you take a right on Park Street for
one block and then a left on Easy Street for one block you come upon a
sign. It reads, "Dead End." Crabtree's implication...Don't take that
last turn!

|